'The Dark Night of the Soul' and the Neurodiverse Mind.

The concept of the "Dark Night of the Soul" has long been a profound element of Christian tradition, describing a period of spiritual desolation and inner darkness that often precedes a deeper union with God. Coined by the 16th-century Spanish mystic St. John of the Cross, this spiritual metaphor has since resonated with countless believers who have faced intense periods of doubt, despair, and emotional suffering. But what does the Dark Night of the Soul mean for neurodivergent individuals and those who struggle with mental illness, whose cognitive and emotional experiences may differ significantly from neurotypical ones?

In this blog post, we will explore how the Dark Night of the Soul intersects with the experiences of neurodivergent individuals, particularly those who experience conditions such as autism, ADHD, bipolar disorder, and obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD). We will examine how spiritual desolation and psychological distress may manifest uniquely in these experiences, and how the journey through this darkness can lead to profound spiritual growth. By engaging with both spiritual and psychological perspectives, we aim to offer a more inclusive understanding of the Dark Night of the Soul.

Understanding the Dark Night of the Soul

Before diving into the neurodivergent experience, it is essential to understand the concept of the Dark Night of the Soul as originally articulated by St. John of the Cross. In his writings, particularly in The Dark Night, St. John describes two distinct phases of the Dark Night: the "Night of the Senses" and the "Night of the Spirit."

1. The Night of the Senses involves a detachment from worldly pleasures and a purification of the soul’s attachment to sensory experiences. During this stage, individuals often feel abandoned by God as they no longer experience the emotional or spiritual consolations that once sustained them.

2. The Night of the Spirit is a deeper, more intense phase where the soul experiences profound inner darkness. Here, individuals may feel as though God is entirely absent, leading to a crisis of faith. This phase is characterized by spiritual desolation, where the soul feels utterly lost and devoid of divine presence.

St. John of the Cross emphasizes that the Dark Night is not a punishment but a necessary purification process that prepares the soul for a more intimate union with God. The darkness is a passageway through which the soul must travel to reach the light on the other side.

Neurodivergence and Spiritual Experience

Neurodivergent individuals often experience the world in ways that differ significantly from neurotypical individuals. This divergence can influence every aspect of life, including spiritual experiences. For many, neurodivergence brings heightened sensitivity, intense emotional experiences, and unique cognitive patterns—all of which can profoundly shape one's spiritual journey.

However, neurodivergent individuals may also face challenges such as heightened anxiety, depressive episodes, or sensory overload, which can complicate their experience of spiritual desolation. These psychological factors can make the Dark Night of the Soul a particularly intense and overwhelming experience for neurodivergent individuals, intertwining spiritual and psychological distress in ways that require careful navigation.

The Dark Night and Autism

Autism spectrum disorder (ASD) is characterized by differences in social communication, sensory processing, and repetitive behaviors. For autistic individuals, the world can be overwhelming, with sensory input often becoming too intense or chaotic to manage. This sensory sensitivity can lead to feelings of isolation, confusion, and emotional exhaustion—experiences that resonate with the spiritual desolation described in The Dark Night of the Soul.

Sensory Overload and Spiritual Desolation

For autistic individuals, the Night of the Senses might be particularly challenging due to their heightened sensitivity to sensory input. The withdrawal of spiritual consolations—the "felt" presence of God—can exacerbate feelings of sensory overload. In a spiritual context, this might manifest as an inability to find solace in prayer or liturgical practices that once provided comfort.

Moreover, the intense focus on detachment from sensory experiences during the Night of the Senses could be experienced as a form of spiritual burnout for autistic individuals. The challenge lies in the paradox that what was once a source of spiritual nourishment may now contribute to an overwhelming sense of emptiness.

Rituals, Routines, and the Night of the Spirit

Autistic individuals often find comfort in routines and rituals, which can provide a sense of stability in a chaotic world. However, during the Night of the Spirit, these routines may no longer bring the same sense of security, leading to a profound sense of spiritual disorientation.

This disorientation can feel like a personal failure or a loss of identity, as the familiar structures that once supported the spiritual life seem to collapse. Yet, this collapse is part of the necessary process of letting go, allowing the soul to move beyond rigid structures and enter into a deeper, more fluid relationship with God.

ADHD and the Struggle with Focus in the Dark Night

Attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) is characterized by inattention, hyperactivity, and impulsivity. Individuals with ADHD often struggle with maintaining focus, managing emotions, and following through with long-term tasks. In the context of the Dark Night of the Soul, these traits can make the journey through spiritual desolation particularly complex.

Inattention and the Night of the Senses

During the Night of the Senses, the withdrawal of spiritual consolations can exacerbate the difficulties that individuals with ADHD face in maintaining focus. Prayer and meditation, which may have been challenging but manageable before, can become nearly impossible when the mind is flooded with distractions and the heart feels distant from God.

This inattention can lead to feelings of guilt or inadequacy, as individuals with ADHD may believe that their inability to focus on spiritual practices is a sign of spiritual failure. However, this experience can also be reframed as part of the purifying process, where the soul is called to find new ways of connecting with God that transcend conventional practices.

Impulsivity and Spiritual Desperation

Impulsivity, a core trait of ADHD, can also complicate the experience of the Night of the Spirit. The intense emotional swings that often accompany ADHD can lead to spiritual desperation during this phase, as individuals may feel an overwhelming urge to seek immediate relief from their inner darkness.

This impulsivity can manifest in attempts to force spiritual experiences or in oscillating between extremes of spiritual fervour and desolation. However, the Night of the Spirit requires patient endurance—a letting go of the need to control or escape the darkness. For individuals with ADHD, this may involve a challenging but transformative process of learning to sit with discomfort and trust in God’s hidden presence.

Bipolar Disorder and the Dark Night’s Emotional Extremes

Bipolar disorder is characterized by alternating periods of mania and depression, which can create a rollercoaster of emotional experiences. The Dark Night of the Soul, with its intense spiritual desolation, can intersect with the depressive phases of bipolar disorder, creating a complex interplay between spiritual and psychological suffering.

Mania and Spiritual Overexcitement

During the manic phase of bipolar disorder, individuals may experience heightened spiritual emotions, such as feelings of divine closeness, grandiosity, or an overwhelming sense of purpose. These experiences can be exhilarating, but they can also lead to spiritual overexcitement, where the individual feels invincible in their spiritual journey.

However, the Dark Night of the Soul can abruptly shift this experience, plunging the individual into a state of spiritual desolation that contrasts sharply with the earlier highs. This sudden change can be disorienting and distressing, leading to confusion and a sense of betrayal by God.

Depression and the Night of the Spirit

The depressive phase of bipolar disorder can deepen the experience of the Night of the Spirit, where the absence of God’s presence feels like a heavy, inescapable burden. For individuals with bipolar disorder, this phase may align with a period of intense psychological despair, where feelings of worthlessness and hopelessness dominate.

Navigating this intersection requires a careful balance of spiritual and psychological care. It is essential to recognize that the feelings of despair during the Night of the Spirit are not signs of spiritual failure but part of the broader journey toward union with God. At the same time, addressing the psychological aspects of bipolar disorder—through therapy, medication, and support—can provide the stability needed to endure this dark phase.

Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder and the Scrupulous Soul

Obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD) is characterized by intrusive thoughts and compulsive behaviours aimed at reducing anxiety. In a spiritual context, OCD can manifest as scrupulosity, where individuals become obsessed with the fear of sinning or not doing enough to please God. This condition can make the Dark Night of the Soul particularly intense, as the spiritual desolation may exacerbate feelings of guilt and fear.

Scrupulosity and the Night of the Senses

For individuals with OCD, the Night of the Senses may involve a painful stripping away of the rituals and behaviours that once provided a sense of spiritual security. The withdrawal of God’s felt presence can trigger intense anxiety, as the individual may feel that they are failing in their spiritual duties or that they are being punished for their perceived sins.

This experience can lead to a cycle of compulsive behaviours aimed at regaining God’s favour or alleviating the fear of damnation. However, the Night of the Senses is an invitation to let go of these compulsions and to trust in God’s grace, even when it feels absent. This letting go is not easy, but it is a crucial step in the journey toward deeper spiritual freedom.

Intrusive Thoughts and the Night of the Spirit

During the Night of the Spirit, individuals with OCD may struggle with intrusive thoughts that challenge their faith and sense of self-worth. These thoughts can be distressing, leading to a deepening sense of spiritual desolation. The key to navigating this phase is to recognize that these thoughts are not a reflection of one’s spiritual state but rather a symptom of OCD.

Engaging in practices such as cognitive-behavioural therapy (CBT) and mindfulness can help individuals manage these intrusive thoughts while maintaining their spiritual focus. The Night of the Spirit, in this context, becomes an opportunity to deepen one’s reliance on God’s grace and to find peace in the midst of mental turmoil.

Spiritual Growth Through the Dark Night: A Neurodivergent Journey

While the Dark Night of the Soul can be a harrowing experience, it also holds the potential for profound spiritual growth, particularly for neurodivergent individuals. The unique challenges posed by neurodivergence can lead to a deeper understanding of the self and a more intimate relationship with God.

Embracing Neurodivergence as Part of the Spiritual Journey

One of the key insights that can emerge from the Dark Night is the recognition that neurodivergence is not a barrier to holiness but a unique aspect of the individual’s spiritual journey. The heightened sensitivities, emotional intensities, and cognitive differences that characterize neurodivergence can be seen as gifts that offer a distinct perspective on the divine.

In the darkness of the Night of the Senses and the Night of the Spirit, neurodivergent individuals may come to understand their experiences not as flaws but as pathways to deeper spiritual insight. This shift in perspective can lead to a greater sense of self-acceptance and a more authentic relationship with God.

Finding New Forms of Prayer and Connection

The Dark Night of the Soul often requires a letting go of old forms of prayer and spiritual practices that no longer resonate. For neurodivergent individuals, this can be an invitation to explore new ways of connecting with God that align with their unique cognitive and emotional needs.

This might involve incorporating sensory-friendly practices, such as nature walks, art, or music, into one’s spiritual life. It might also mean embracing periods of silence and solitude, where the mind can rest from overstimulation and simply be in God’s presence. By finding new forms of prayer and connection, neurodivergent individuals can create a spiritual life that is both meaningful and sustainable.

Integrating Psychological Support

It is important to recognize that spiritual desolation and psychological distress are not mutually exclusive, and addressing both is crucial for overall well-being. For neurodivergent individuals, integrating psychological support—such as therapy, medication, and community care—can provide the stability needed to navigate the Dark Night of the Soul.

St. John of the Cross emphasized that the Dark Night is not an end in itself but a passage to greater light. For neurodivergent individuals, this passage may involve a combination of spiritual and psychological practices that support both the soul and the mind.

Conclusion: The Dark Night as a Universal and Unique Experience

The Dark Night of the Soul is a universal experience that transcends individual differences, but it is also uniquely shaped by the particularities of each person’s life. For neurodivergent individuals, the intersection of spiritual desolation and psychological distress offers both profound challenges and opportunities for growth.

By embracing neurodivergence as part of the spiritual journey, finding new forms of prayer and connection, and integrating psychological support, neurodivergent individuals can navigate the Dark Night with resilience and grace. In doing so, they may discover a deeper, more authentic relationship with God—one that honours the full complexity of their human experience.

The journey through the Dark Night is never easy, but it is a journey that holds the promise of transformation. For neurodivergent individuals, this transformation is not about becoming something other than what they are, but about discovering the divine light within their unique way of being. In the end, the Dark Night of the Soul is not just a period of darkness but a passage to the fullness of life in God.

---

Recommended Academic References:

1. John of the Cross, The Dark Night of the Soul. Translated by E. Allison Peers. New York: Image Books, 1959.

2. Lawson, Michael S. "Spiritual Desolation in the Dark Night of the Soul." Journal of Spiritual Formation and Soul Care 10, no. 2 (2017): 197-211.

3. Baron-Cohen, Simon. The Pattern Seekers: How Autism Drives Human Invention. New York: Basic Books, 2020.

4. Kavanaugh, Kieran, and Otilio Rodriguez, eds. The Collected Works of St. John of the Cross. Washington, D.C.: ICS Publications, 1991.

5. Siegel, Daniel J. The Mindful Brain: Reflection and Attunement in the Cultivation of Well-Being. New York: W. W. Norton & Company, 2007.

6. Warner, Michael. "Neurodiversity and Spirituality: A Theological Approach." Journal of Disability & Religion 24, no. 1 (2020): 5-21.